How Real PAR Data Changed My Planted Tank Lighting Forever!
For this article, I want to share a few important things I learned while PAR testing the aquarium lights I use on my planted tanks.
While this topic might sound a bit technical at first—especially if you’re new to planted aquariums—the information is actually very practical.
Having real, measurable data completely changed how I think about aquarium lighting, and it’s helped me make better decisions when choosing and setting up lights for healthy plant growth.
What Is PAR And SPD?

Before going any further, it’s important to understand what PAR and SPD actually mean.
These two terms come up a lot when talking about aquarium lighting, but many people focus only on PAR, even though both play an important role in plant growth.
What Is PAR?
PAR, or Photosynthetically Active Radiation, refers to the amount of usable light a fixture provides for plants.
In simple terms, PAR tells us how much light energy is available for photosynthesis.
Currently, PAR is defined as light within the 400 to 700 nanometer range1, which covers most of the visible spectrum.
This is the range plants have traditionally been thought to use for growth.
However, research by Dr. Bruce Bugbee, suggests this definition may need updating.
His work shows that wavelengths slightly beyond this range—between 700 and 750 nanometers—can also provide meaningful benefits for plant growth2.
What Is SPD?
SPD, or Spectral Power Distribution, describes how the light from a fixture is spread across the spectrum3.
Instead of focusing on how much light there is overall, SPD shows how much of that light comes from different colors, such as blue, green, and red.
This is important because aquarium plants don’t use all colors of light equally.
Why Blue And Red Light Matter For Plants
Chlorophyll, the pigment plants use to photosynthesize, has two main absorption peaks in the visible spectrum:
- A strong peak in the blue range, around 430–450 nanometers
- Another strong peak in the red range, around 640–675 nanometers
Both of these areas play a key role in healthy plant growth4, and an aquarium light that supports both can be more effective than one that doesn’t.
PAR vs SPD: A Simple Way To Think About It
An easy way to remember the difference is:
- PAR = how much usable light is available for plant growth
- SPD = how usable light is distributed across different colors
When choosing an aquarium light, both of these factors matter—not just the PAR number on the box.
Cheap Lights Can Perform Very Well

One of the key takeaways from my testing is that affordable LED aquarium lights can perform exceptionally well for easy category plant growth.
You don’t automatically need to spend a lot of money to get good results in a low-tech planted tank.
To keep things clear, I have compiled a table showing all the lights I tested, along with their PAR readings and SPD peaks, expressed as a percentage relative to their blue light output.
This made it far easier to compare how different lights actually perform, rather than relying on marketing claims.
| Light | PAR | Blue | Green | Red | Depth Measured | Length | Watts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Seaoura SR657 | 155 | 100% | 39% | 28% | 25cm | 30-45cm | 14 |
| Hygger 957 | 124 | 100% | 38% | 29% | 30cm | 90-107cm | 60 |
| Seaoura SR616 | 123 | 100% | 41% | 31% | 23cm | 30-45cm | 10 |
| Chihiros AII | 101 | 100% | 67% | 45% | 25cm | 45cm | 21 |
| Seaoura SR659 | 99 | 100% | 52% | 43% | 25cm | 45-60cm | 22 |
| Chihiros AII | 85 | 100% | 61% | 40% | 20cm | 40cm | 18 |
| Chihiros AII | 82 | 100% | 56% | 34% | 30cm | 30cm | 15 |
| Seaoura SR653 | 73 | 100% | 50% | 62% | 25cm | 45-60cm | 16 |
| Hygger HG76 | 71 | 100% | 26% | 21% | 25cm | 45-60cm | 18 |
| Hygger 957 | 61 | 100% | 35% | 28% | 30cm | 30-45cm | 20 |
| Nicrew C10 | 43 | 100% | 60% | 33% | 30cm | 88-115cm | 28 |
A Real-World Example: Seaoura SR616
If you’re familiar with my content, you’ve probably seen me recommend the Seaoura SR616 quite a lot.
It has always performed very well for me and, in my experience, has even outperformed several lights that cost significantly more.
I use many of these lights throughout my fish room, but PAR testing them helped me understand why they work so well, not just that they do.
The readings shown here are from one of my Seaoura SR616 lights, specifically the smallest 10-watt version but all of my units produced very similar results.

What The Results Show
This light produced around 123 PAR, along with a well-balanced SPD relative to its low price point.
For beginner and intermediate planted tanks, this is more than enough light to grow a wide range of plants successfully.
These results line up perfectly with my own long-term experience using this light and also help explain why it currently has over 5,000 reviews on Amazon, with an average rating of 4.5 stars.
Do You Really Need Expensive Lighting?
If your goal is to grow easy plants or even some medium-difficulty plants, there’s no need to invest in expensive, high-end lighting.
Budget-friendly options like the Seaoura SR616 can deliver excellent results when used correctly.
Brands Can Inflate PAR By Taking Advantage Of A Poor SPD

Another important thing I noticed during testing is that some brands can make a light look better on paper by inflating PAR numbers, often by heavily focusing on blue light.
I won’t name the specific light whose SPD chart is shown above, as it isn’t one I recommend, but it serves as a good example for this point.
When you look at its SPD, the blue peak is very strong, while the green and red peaks are low by comparison.
Why This Can Be A Problem
As mentioned earlier, chlorophyll has a major absorption peak in the red part of the spectrum.
If a light lacks enough red output, overall plant growth can suffer—even if the PAR number looks high.
In these cases, a large portion of the advertised PAR is coming almost entirely from the blue spectrum.
While blue light is important, it shouldn’t dominate the spectrum to this extent.
How PAR Numbers Can Be Misleading
Focusing heavily on blue light also allows manufacturers to advertise strong PAR readings at commonly used aquarium depths like 12 inches (30 cm).
Blue light penetrates water more effectively than red light5, so PAR readings taken at depth can look impressive.
The issue is that high PAR doesn’t automatically mean good plant growth.
If the spectrum isn’t balanced, you may run into problems.
Real-World Impact In Planted Tanks
This is where hobbyists can get caught out.
You might see high PAR numbers, assume the light is perfect, and then struggle to grow things like:
In many cases, the problem isn’t the amount of light, but how that light is distributed across the spectrum.
A well-balanced SPD is just as important as PAR when it comes to growing healthy aquarium plants.
PAR Ratings On The Box Often Mean Very Little

Another major takeaway from my testing is that the PAR and SPD numbers shown on product boxes and sales pages are often unreliable.
Out of all the aquarium lights I tested, not a single one matched the SPD graphs shown in its product listing.
In many cases, the real-world results were nowhere close.
Why Advertised PAR And SPD Can Be Misleading
Based on what I saw, it’s likely that many manufacturers are either:
- Making them up
- Using testing methods that make the numbers look as good as possible
For example, a PAR meter may be placed directly against the light, instead of being measured where plants actually grow—under water, at the substrate level.
The problem with this approach is simple: that’s not where aquarium plants live, so those numbers don’t help hobbyists make good decisions.
Not Every Light Is Overhyped

That said, it’s not all bad news.
There are exceptions.
In a recent short I made about the Seaoura SR659—a more powerful WRGB version of the SR616—the advertised PAR value on the box was actually more than 10% lower than what I measured in real-world testing.
However, these cases were the minority.
Two Lights With Similar PAR Can Perform Very Differently

Another key thing to understand is that two aquarium lights can have very similar PAR readings but still perform very differently when it comes to plant growth.
The reason for this usually comes down to differences in SPD, not PAR.
A Side-by-Side Example

A good example of this is the Seaoura SR653 compared to the Hygger HG76.
When tested, both lights produced very similar PAR values, but their spectral output told a different story.
The green and red peaks varied noticeably between the two fixtures, mainly because of the type and number of LEDs used in each light.
Full Spectrum vs WRB Lighting
It’s worth clarifying the design difference between these two lights:
- The Hygger HG76 is a standard full-spectrum aquarium light.
- The Seaoura SR653 is a WRB light.
With the SR653, the green output is fixed, while the white, red, and blue channels can be adjusted independently.
This allows for a more targeted spectral output, although it’s important to note that the light was tested straight out of the box, with no custom adjustments made.
Both lights are sold at a similar price point, so the comparison is fair.
Does This Matter For Plant Growth?
For easy, low-demand plants, this difference may not be very noticeable, as many beginner plants will grow just fine under either light.
However, as you move into higher-difficulty plants, the stronger red peak found in some lights can start to matter more.
This is due to chlorophyll’s second major absorption peak in the red wavelength range6, which plays an important role in photosynthesis.
Beam Spread Matters More Than You Might Think

Another important observation from my testing is that beam spread makes a big difference.
Beam spread refers to how evenly a light fixture distributes light across the aquarium, not just how strong it is in the center.
Light Isn’t Evenly Distributed
Every light I tested produced its highest PAR directly under the fixture.
However, when I moved the PAR meter toward the front, back, or sides of the tank, some lights showed a noticeable drop in intensity.
This drop-off was less noticeable with Chihiros, Hygger, and Seaoura lights, but with some other brands, PAR levels fell sharply with just a few centimeters of movement away from the center.
This can lead to uneven plant growth, with strong growth in the middle and weaker growth around the edges.
Why Some Lights Spread Better Than Others
I can’t say for certain whether Chihiros, Hygger, and Seaoura intentionally designed their lights for better beam spread, or if it’s simply a result of their overall design.
All three brands use wider fixtures, which helps with heat dissipation and keeps the LEDs cooler.
This wider design also allows LEDs to be spread further from front to back, resulting in more even light coverage across the tank.
Don’t Forget Hardscape And Plants
It’s also important to remember that hardscape and plants themselves block light.
Rocks, wood, and dense plant growth can all cause noticeable PAR loss below them.
When planning your aquascape, keep this in mind.
There’s little benefit in placing high-light plants in areas where a large portion of the light will be blocked before it ever reaches them.
White LEDs Emit The Full Spectrum

This is something I already understood, but using a PAR meter with SPD data helped clearly demonstrate it in practice.
The SPD readings from my Chihiros AII lights show that, despite using only white LEDs, they still cover the full visible light spectrum.
Why “Full Spectrum” Is Often Misunderstood

I’ve received some pushback on this point previously, and it usually comes down to confusion about what full spectrum actually means.
White light does emit the entire visible spectrum7, but it does so with relatively even intensity rather than strong peaks in specific colors.
Because of this, lights made up entirely of white LEDs typically need more overall power to maintain strong red output under water, especially at greater depths.
White LEDs vs RGB and WRGB Lights

By comparison, full-spectrum lights that use separate red, green, and blue LEDs can produce similar color output using less power.
This can offer a few advantages, such as:
- Lower electricity costs
- More precise color control
- Stronger red or RGB output in more affordable fixtures
This difference in design helps explain why some budget lights can perform well, while others struggle.
Why Shop Lights Can Still Grow Plants
This is also why some people see great plant growth using shop lights or security flood lights, which usually rely on white LEDs only.
These lights do emit the full spectrum, and their initial purchase cost is often low.
However, to generate enough usable light for certain plants, they often need to run at higher power levels, which can result in higher electricity usage compared to purpose-built full-spectrum aquarium lights.
Floating Plants Change Everything

This is a point I’ve mentioned in several recent videos, and PAR testing really helped highlight just how much of an impact floating plants can have.
Some of the lights I tested, lights lost more than 75% of their usable light when floating plants were present, compared to aquariums without them.
That’s a massive difference.
Why Floating Plant Maintenance Matters
Because floating plants sit directly under the light, they block and absorb a large amount of it before it ever reaches the plants below.
This makes regular floating plant maintenance especially important if you’re trying to grow:
Simply removing excess floating plant mass can dramatically increase how much light reaches the substrate.
Why You Rarely See Floating Plants In High-End Aquascapes
This also helps explain why floating plants are rarely used in high-end aquascapes.
While they have many benefits, they block too much light for layouts that rely on strong, even lighting across the entire tank.
Personally, I’ve been removing floating plants from many of my own tanks.
I prefer the look of carpeting plants, and they require as much light as possible—especially when using more affordable lighting.
Floating Plants Still Have Their Place
That said, floating plants are still an excellent addition to many aquariums.
They:
- Absorb large amounts of excess nutrients
- Provide cover and security for fish
- Help improve overall tank stability
So don’t go ripping out your floating plants just because of this.
If your plants are growing well, there’s no problem at all. Just keep this in mind if you’re struggling with plants that have higher light requirements.
Mounting Height Can Matter More Than Light Strength

Another important lesson from this testing is that how high your light is mounted above the tank can sometimes matter more than how powerful the light is on paper.
A Comparison Between Two Similar Lights
On paper, the Hygger 957 and the Hygger HG76 have almost identical output.
The HG76 is the newer model and offers better power efficiency, and when I measured PAR directly underneath each light, the readings matched what the specs suggested.
However, the way these two lights are mounted is very different.
- The Hygger 957 sits flat across the top of the aquarium.
- The Hygger HG76 uses a built-in riser that lifts the light about 2 inches (5 cm) higher above the water.
Why Height Makes A Difference

This difference in mounting height became obvious when measuring PAR deeper in the tank.
About a quarter of the way down the aquarium, the HG76’s light intensity began to drop off faster than the 957’s.
While the number and type of LEDs in a fixture also matter, mounting height clearly played a role here.
At the substrate level, the PAR meter showed that the HG76 had lost around 12% more PAR than the 957.
Real-World Results Still Matter

That said, the HG76 is still capable of growing plants well.
I’ve successfully grown a carpet of Helanthium tenellum ‘Green’ under it, and its improved power efficiency does slightly reduce electricity usage.
Still, it does make me wonder how much faster or denser that same carpet might grow if the Hygger 957 were used on the exact same tank.
Shallow Tanks Are Easier To Overlight
Following on from the point about mounting height, the final thing I want to cover is how much easier it is to overlight shallow aquariums.
Tank Depth Makes A Big Difference

All three aquariums on the middle shelf of my rack above fall within the recommended width for the 20-watt Hygger 957.
However, they aren’t all the same depth.
Two of them are 35 cm tall portrait tanks, while the third is a 25 cm tall rectangular tank.
As mentioned throughout this article, light continues to lose intensity as it travels through water.
This means the amount of PAR reaching the substrate at 25 cm is significantly higher than at 35 cm, even when using the same light at the same settings.
The Pros And Cons Of Shallow Tanks
This difference in depth comes with both advantages and disadvantages.
The main advantage is that high-light-requirement plants are usually easier to grow in shallow tanks, because more usable light reaches the bottom.
The downside is that any excess light that plants don’t use can be taken advantage of by algae, which can lead to more frequent algae problems if lighting isn’t adjusted.
Adjusting Light Intensity Matters
Thankfully, all of the lights I use allow for easy intensity adjustment, regardless of brand or model.
This makes it much easier to fine-tune lighting for different tank depths.
It’s also important to remember that what works for me won’t automatically work for you.
For example, when people ask about the settings on my Hygger 957 over my betta tank, I tell them I run it at maximum intensity for six hours a day—because that setup works well in that specific tank.
However, if I take that exact same light and move it from a 35 cm deep portrait tank to a 25 cm deep rectangular tank, I’d likely need to reduce the intensity to around 80% for the same six hours to avoid algae issues in the shallower aquarium.
Final Thoughts
PAR testing completely changed the way I look at aquarium lighting, and hopefully this article has helped clear up some of the confusion around what actually matters when choosing a light for a planted tank.
The biggest takeaway is that more expensive doesn’t automatically mean better, and high PAR numbers on a box don’t guarantee good plant growth.
Things like spectrum balance (SPD), beam spread, mounting height, tank depth, and even floating plants can have just as much—if not more—impact than raw power alone.
If you’re new to planted tanks, don’t feel like you need to chase perfect numbers or buy the most powerful light available.
Start simple, choose a light that’s appropriate for your tank size and plant choices, and adjust as you go. Most plant issues can be solved by small changes to lighting intensity or duration, rather than upgrading equipment.
At the end of the day, every aquarium is different.
What works in my tanks won’t always work exactly the same in yours, but understanding why things work gives you a much better chance of success.
Good luck with your planted tanks, and don’t be afraid to experiment—you’ll learn more from observing your plants than from any spec sheet.
Sources
- Photosynthetically Active Radiation – https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sciences/photosynthetically-active-radiation ↩︎
- Far-red photons have equivalent efficiency to traditional photosynthetic photons: Implications for redefining photosynthetically active radiation – https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31990071/ ↩︎
- Spectral Power Distribution – https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/agricultural-and-biological-sciences/spectral-power-distribution ↩︎
- Chlorophylls and Light-Harvesting Complexes – https://research.vu.nl/ws/portalfiles/portal/229112338/Chlorophylls_and_Light_Harvesting_Complexes.pdf ↩︎
- Light in the Ocean – https://manoa.hawaii.edu/exploringourfluidearth/physical/ocean-depths/light-ocean ↩︎
- A Novel Method for Estimating Chlorophyll and Carotenoid Concentrations in Leaves: A Two Hyperspectral Sensor Approach – https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10143517/ ↩︎
- Newton’s Rainbow – https://library.si.edu/exhibition/color-in-a-new-light/science ↩︎