Hygger HG160 Vs Seaoura SR659: Which Aquarium Light Is Better?
Hygger has been one of the biggest names in affordable aquarium equipment for years and, for a long time, its aquarium lights were among my most recommended options for low-tech planted tanks.
However, over the last few years, the planted tank lighting market has become far more competitive, with several manufacturers releasing products that offer significantly more features and performance for similar prices.
This article started as something very different.
Originally, I was discussing a sponsored collaboration with Hygger to independently compare its new HG160 aquarium light against the Seaoura SR659 using PAR, Lux, Spectral Power Distribution (SPD), power consumption, and several other objective measurements.
Unfortunately, that comparison never happened.
In this article, I’ll explain what happened during those discussions, why the collaboration ultimately didn’t go ahead, and then compare the HG160 against the Seaoura SR659 and several other aquarium lights using the information and independent testing available.
| Metric | Hygger HG160 | Seaoura SR659 |
|---|---|---|
| Price | £37.99 | £38.99 |
| Lumens | 756 | 2142 |
| Watts | 24 | 22 |
| Lumens per Watt | 31.5 | 97.4 |
| Amazon Returns | Frequently Returned | Usually Kept |
| Rating | ⭐⭐☆☆☆ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Verdict | ❌ | ✅ |
In short: Based on Hygger’s published specifications and my independent testing of competing lights, I currently recommend the Seaoura SR659.
It offers substantially higher published light output, lower power consumption, independently verified PAR performance, and costs almost the same.
Glass Box Diaries Rating System
| Rating | Meaning |
|---|---|
| ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Outstanding. Among the very best products currently available in their price category. These products combine excellent performance, build quality, ease of use, and value for money. I would happily recommend them without hesitation. |
| ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ | Excellent. Easy to recommend and likely to satisfy most aquarists. Minor compromises prevent a perfect score, but they still offer excellent overall value. |
| ⭐⭐⭐☆☆ | Good. A solid product that performs well, but stronger alternatives exist depending on your priorities, budget, or aquarium setup. |
| ⭐⭐☆☆☆ | Below Average. Functional and usable, but difficult to recommend because competing products generally offer better performance, features, or value for a similar price. |
| ⭐☆☆☆☆ | Poor. Major compromises, design flaws, reliability concerns, or consistently better alternatives make these products difficult to recommend. |
What Happened?

On 9 June 2026, Hygger contacted me to discuss a potential collaboration.
As with any sponsorship enquiry, I replied with my media kit and rate card.
While I’m always happy to work with manufacturers, I generally only accept product exchange collaborations if they’re for products that are genuinely interesting enough to dedicate a full review or comparison to.
A few days later, while working on an update to my annual guide on the best low-tech planted tank lights, I became curious about Hygger’s latest release.
I wanted to see how it compared with the newest lights from Seaoura, which have become some of my favourite budget aquarium lights over the past year.
When I asked Hygger what their newest planted tank light was, they said it was the HG160.
Proposing An Independent Comparison

Rather than producing a standard product review, I suggested comparing the Hygger HG160 directly against the Seaoura SR659.
Both lights are the newest planted tank models from their respective brands and are sold at very similar prices, making them what I considered to be the fairest comparison.
Hygger responded positively to the idea and asked how I planned to test both lights.
I explained that the comparison would be based on objective measurements rather than subjective opinions, including:
- PAR testing
- Lux testing
- Spectral Power Distribution (SPD)
- Build quality
- Customisation features
- Efficiency (PAR per watt)
- Power consumption
- Heat generation
All light measurements would be taken using an ITC PARwise meter rented from Parmeterhire.co.uk rather than a smartphone application.
After discussing the testing methodology, Hygger confirmed they were happy to move forward with the collaboration, and I was genuinely looking forward to independently testing the HG160.

The Collaboration Started To Change
About a week later, Hygger contacted me again and explained that, because the HG160 was still a new product, they would prefer a dedicated review rather than a direct comparison against the Seaoura SR659.
This surprised me because the HG160 was already in production and available for sale at full retail price1, so I wasn’t sure why a comparison with a similarly priced competitor was no longer the preferred approach.
Although a standalone review wasn’t my original plan, I agreed to update the proposed deliverables so the collaboration could continue.
The UK Availability Issue

Shortly afterwards, the situation changed again.
After moving away from the comparison, Hygger claimed that the HG160 had not been released in the UK, despite Hygger already knowing I was based in the UK for several weeks.
This was confusing because I was able to find an active Amazon UK product listing for the HG1602.
After I pointed this out, Hygger claimed that while the light was available to purchase in the UK (even though they claimed it hadn’t even launched), it was not available through their UK creator sponsorship programme.

I’ll let readers decide what they think about that explanation.
I don’t know Hygger’s reasoning, but given the timing, I suspect they reconsidered the comparison after reviewing how their light compared with the Seaoura SR659.
Regardless of how the collaboration ended, I still think the original comparison is worth discussing.
Before drawing any conclusions, let’s compare the available data and see how the Hygger HG160 stacks up against the Seaoura SR659 and several other planted tank lights.
The Comparison

This isn’t the comparison I originally planned to publish.
I intended to independently test both the Hygger HG160 and the Seaoura SR659 using the same methodology, including PAR, Lux, Spectral Power Distribution (SPD), power consumption, and heat generation.
Since that comparison never took place, the information below combines my own independent testing of the Seaoura SR659 and several other lights with Hygger’s published specifications for the HG1601.
Wherever possible, I’ll clearly distinguish between independent testing and manufacturer claims.
It’s also worth mentioning that I personally own every other aquarium light discussed later in this article.
I’ve used them for at least eleven months—most of them for several years—and have independently measured their PAR and SPD output using an ITC PARwise meter.
Amazon Customer Signals
Before looking at the technical specifications, I noticed something interesting on Amazon UK.
Despite only being available for a relatively short time, the Hygger HG160 already carries Amazon’s “Frequently Returned Item” warning2.

By comparison, the Seaoura SR659 carries the “Customers Usually Keep This Item” label, despite being available for considerably longer3.

These labels shouldn’t be treated as scientific measurements of product quality, but they can provide a useful indication of customer satisfaction and return rates.
Price Comparison
| 30–45CM | 45–60CM | 90–105CM | 120–135CM | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hygger HG160 | 32.99 | 37.99 | 59.99 | 72.99 |
| Seaoura SR659 | 30.99 | 38.99 | 59.99 | 65.99 |
| Price Difference | +6% | +3% | 0% | +11% |
Looking at the current Amazon UK pricing, both lights occupy a very similar price bracket.
Across the four available sizes, the Seaoura SR659 is cheaper in two sizes, the same price in one, and only slightly more expensive in the remaining model.
On price alone, neither light has a significant advantage.
Light Output
| Tank Size | Hygger | Seaoura | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 30–45cm | 591 lm | 1160 lm | 2.0× brighter |
| 45–60cm | 756 lm | 2142 lm | 2.8× brighter |
| 90–105cm | 1459 lm | 3721 lm | 2.6× brighter |
| 120–135cm | 1659 lm | 4082 lm | 2.5× brighter |
This is where the comparison becomes much more interesting.
According to Hygger’s own published specifications, the 45–60 cm HG160 produces substantially fewer lumens than the equivalent Seaoura SR659 despite selling at a very similar price.
Normally, I prefer using PAR rather than lumens when evaluating planted tank lights because PAR is a far better indicator of the light available for photosynthesis.
Unfortunately, Hygger does not publish PAR values for the HG160.
Instead, the specification simply refers to “high PAR” without providing any measured figures, making it impossible to independently assess that claim using the published information alone.

Seaoura, on the other hand, publishes PAR figures for the SR659.
When I independently tested the 45–60 cm model using an ITC PARwise meter, I measured a substrate-level PAR of 99. Seaoura’s published specification lists the same model at 89 PAR3.
While that doesn’t prove every specification published by Seaoura is perfectly accurate, it does demonstrate that, in my testing, the company’s published PAR figure was conservative rather than exaggerated.
Power Consumption
| 30–45CM | 45–60CM | 90–105CM | 120–135CM | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hygger HG160 | 18 W | 24 W | 46 W | 58 W |
| Seaoura SR659 | 14 W | 22 W | 42 W | 48 W |
| Relative Wattage | 78% | 92% | 91% | 83% |
Power consumption raises another interesting point.
According to Hygger’s own specifications, the HG160 consumes more watts than the equivalent Seaoura SR659 despite its considerably lower light output.
If those published figures are accurate, it would mean paying more to run a light that produces less output while also potentially generating more heat because of the higher electrical consumption.
Control System
The HG160 includes five lighting modes, eight colour presets, and ten brightness levels; however, these features have become standard within this price range.
The Seaoura SR659 offers similar scheduling functionality while also providing independent WRGB colour adjustment through its S3 mode, allowing considerably more control over the appearance of the aquarium.
Alternative Aquarium Lights

Before looking at some alternatives, I should explain why brands such as Nicrew and FZONE aren’t included in this comparison.
I have nothing against either manufacturer.
However, Nicrew hasn’t released a new planted tank light since 2024, while most of FZONE’s lighting range hasn’t been released in the UK yet.
Since I haven’t been able to test their latest products, I don’t think it would be fair to include them.
Hygger 957

If you’re determined to buy a Hygger light, I actually think one of the company’s older models currently represents much better value.
The Hygger 957 was originally released in either 2020 or 2021, depending on your region.
I’ve purchased several of these lights with my own money over the years, used them extensively, and until recently, they were among my most recommended aquarium lights.
What’s surprising is that, despite being five to six years older than the HG160, the 957 still compares very well.
Across many sizes, the prices are similar, power consumption is comparable, yet the older 957 offers significantly higher published lumen output.
That said, I also think the 957 is beginning to show its age.
Even with its advantages over the HG160, it still falls well behind the Seaoura SR659.
I’ve independently tested several Hygger 957 lights using an ITC PARwise meter.
For reference, my 22-watt Hygger 957 measured 61 PAR at substrate level, while the similarly sized 20-watt Seaoura SR659 measured 99 PAR under the same testing methodology.

Seaoura SR653

If you’re open to alternatives from other manufacturers, the Seaoura SR653 is another light worth considering.
Although it’s positioned below the SR659 in Seaoura’s range, it still comes in at a lower price than the HG160 while offering lower power consumption, higher published light output and WRB colour customisation4.

Seaoura SR657

The Seaoura SR657 is another strong competitor.
Despite being on the market for around two years, it’s still more affordable than the HG160, consumes less electricity, and offers higher published light output5.
Like the other Seaoura lights mentioned in this article, I’ve independently tested the SR657 using an ITC PARwise meter.
You can find the full PAR and SPD results for every aquarium light I’ve tested in my independent light check article.

Final Verdict

Looking purely at the information available today, I don’t think the Hygger HG160 represents particularly good value for money.
Based on Hygger’s own published specifications, the HG160 offers very low light output for its price while also having higher power consumption than several competing planted tank lights.
Without published PAR data, it’s also difficult to independently assess Hygger’s claims about the light’s performance for aquatic plants.
By comparison, the Seaoura SR659 delivers a stronger overall package.
Not only have I independently verified its PAR performance using an ITC PARwise meter, but my testing also showed Seaoura’s published PAR figure to be conservative rather than exaggerated.
Combined with its competitive pricing, lower power consumption, and flexible WRGB customisation, it currently sets the benchmark for affordable low-tech planted tank lighting in my opinion.
That doesn’t mean I want Hygger to fail. Quite the opposite.
For years, Hygger produced some of the best-value planted tank lights available, and I’d genuinely like to see the company become more competitive again.
Strong competition benefits everyone by encouraging manufacturers to improve their products, innovate faster, and offer better value for fishkeepers.
At the moment, however, I think there are better options available at this price point.
I update my guide to the best low-tech planted aquarium lights every year, giving you easy access to up-to-date, reliable recommendations for your own aquarium.
Sources
- Hygger HG160 – https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0FZTW8JXR ↩︎
- Hygger HG160 – https://www.amazon.co.uk/hygger-Controller-Adjustable-Brightness-Extendable/dp/B0FPFN2P3G/ ↩︎
- Seaoura SR659 – https://www.amazon.co.uk/SEAOURA-Temperature-Programmable-Brightness-Freshwater/dp/B0FCMS9KZT/ ↩︎
- Seaoura SR653 – https://www.amazon.co.uk/SEAOURA-Freshwater-Customizable-Brightness-Adjustable/dp/B0F3XPJB7B/ ↩︎
- Seaoura SR657 – https://www.amazon.co.uk/Power-Off-SEAOURA-Brightness-Adjustable-Freshwater/dp/B0DG5P6M7L/ ↩︎