Fish For 40 Gallon Tanks: What I’ve Successfully Kept Together!

If you’re looking for inspiration on how to stock a 40-gallon community aquarium, this guide will walk you through the fish and invertebrates I currently keep together in mine.

Unlike many stocking lists you’ll find online, these species aren’t just theoretical — they’ve all been living together in this setup for about 18 months without any problems.

The tank is kept at 23°C (73°F), with my tap water parameters coming out at pH 6.4, GH 4, and KH 3. I perform a 40% water change about once a month, so these values can fluctuate slightly depending on the timing of maintenance.

Since stocking numbers vary depending on your individual setup and filtration, I won’t be listing exact counts for each species.

Honey Gourami

One Of My Honey Gourami
One Of My Honey Gourami

I keep two male honey gourami in this tank, which I originally added as potential centerpiece fish.

They’re fantastic little fish — easy to care for, peaceful with their tank mates, and full of personality.

That said, they don’t always stand out as a true centerpiece since they spend much of their day tucked away among plants and hardscape.

Behavior And Personality

Like other anabantoids (such as bettas and paradise fish), honey gourami enjoy cover to retreat into.

When they do venture out, they’re fascinating to watch.

Their modified ventral fins act almost like tiny arms, helping them “feel” objects in their surroundings.

Compatibility

Unlike some of the larger gourami species, honey gourami are calm and non-aggressive.

I’ve never seen mine bother other fish, and they’ll even swim past baby shrimp without paying them any attention.

Care Tips

For a peaceful 40-gallon community tank, honey gourami make an excellent choice — just be sure to provide plenty of hiding places with plants, decorations, or other structures to help them feel secure.

Siamese Algae Eater

My Siamese Algae Eater
My Siamese Algae Eater

I only have a single Siamese algae eater in this tank, but it has become something of an unofficial centerpiece simply because it’s the largest fish here.

Behavior And Personality

This fish has been fantastic at controlling algae, but beyond that, it’s just entertaining to watch.

It often gets itself into strange situations while hunting down bits of food that my shrimp have dragged away, and it has a habit of sleeping in the oddest positions — sometimes choosing awkward spots over perfectly smooth leaves.

Like my honey gourami, it enjoys having plenty of hiding places.

It goes through phases of staying tucked away for long periods, followed by bursts of high activity in the open swimming areas.

How To Identify A True Siamese Algae Eater

There are several similar-looking species in the hobby, and some of them can be aggressive.

Luckily, identifying a real Siamese algae eater is straightforward if you know what to look for:

  • The black horizontal stripe should continue all the way into the tail, not stop at the base.
  • The dorsal fin should be completely transparent, with no coloration.

If both of these are present, you’re looking at the real deal.

Compatibility

While mine occasionally nudges my Corydoras out of the way during feeding time, I’ve never seen any other signs of aggression.

In my experience, it’s a peaceful and helpful addition to the community.

Neon Tetra

One Of My Neon Tetras
One Of My Neon Tetras

Neon tetras are one of the most recognizable and popular fish in the aquarium hobby, known for their striking colors, ease of care, and peaceful temperament.

They’re a staple in many community tanks, and it’s easy to see why.

The Downsides

Unfortunately, their popularity has also led to widespread mass breeding, which has caused inbreeding issues.

As a result, many captive-bred neon tetras are less hardy than they once were.

Even in tanks with perfect water parameters, it’s not uncommon to lose some due to genetic weaknesses rather than water quality or care mistakes.

My Experience

I still enjoy keeping neon tetras and appreciate the splash of color they bring to the tank.

However, for beginners looking for their first schooling fish, I believe there are more reliable options available that offer the same beauty with greater hardiness.

Cardinal Tetra

My Siamese Algae Eater With Cardinal Tetras
My Siamese Algae Eater With Cardinal Tetras

Cardinal tetras look very similar to neon tetras but, in my experience — and the experience of many other aquarists — they tend to be much hardier.

This makes them a more reliable choice for community tanks.

How To Tell Them Apart

The easiest way to distinguish cardinals from neons is by their coloration.

On a neon tetra, the red stripe stops partway down the body, leaving a white belly.

On a cardinal tetra, the red stripe runs the entire length of the lower half of the fish.

Cost vs. Value

Cardinal tetras are slightly more expensive than neons in my area, but their higher survival rate makes the extra cost worthwhile.

Behavior And Tank Preferences

In terms of behavior, both species are quite similar.

They spend most of their time calmly exploring the tank and usually only group up tightly when stressed or if something is wrong.

One thing I’ve observed with both cardinals and neons is that, while they often enjoy swimming in open water, they also appreciate having hiding spots.

This becomes especially noticeable when they’re housed with more active tank mates.

For example, when my harlequin rasboras or Corydoras start breeding and become more energetic, the tetras tend to retreat into the plant cover.

Harlequin Rasbora

Harlequin Rasbora
Harlequin Rasbora

Harlequin rasboras are fantastic community fish — they’re easy to find, affordable, hardy, and very straightforward to care for.

While their appearance may not appeal to everyone, I personally think they look stunning in a planted aquarium.

Behavior And Activity

These rasboras are a lot of fun to watch, especially during breeding season when their energy levels increase dramatically.

Compared to my tetras, they tend to stick closer to their group, and from time to time, they’ll shoal around the tank together.

That said, they don’t form tight shoals consistently enough to recommend them if you’re specifically looking for a tight schooling species.

Care And Group Size

Since harlequins are social fish, I recommend keeping at least ten in a 40-gallon tank to help them feel comfortable and display their best behavior.

They’re also confident swimmers, spending most of their time in open areas, and they’re usually the first fish at the surface when food is offered.

Chili Rasbora

Chili Rasboras under the duckweed in one of my aquariums
Chili Rasboras under the duckweed in one of my aquariums

Chili rasboras are tiny but stunning fish.

I don’t have many left in this tank, as their lifespan is only around two to three years, and they spent some time in another setup before being moved here.

Size And Appearance

These fish only grow to just over an inch (about 2.5 cm), which makes them a little difficult to spot in a larger aquarium like a 40-gallon.

Accidental mislabeling is also common with chili rasboras and other members of the Boraras genus, since five of the six known species look very similar until they’ve fully colored up.

In fact, I’m fairly sure I have at least one strawberry rasbora mixed in with my group.

Best Tank Setup

Because of their small size, chili rasboras are often better suited to smaller tanks where they can be seen and appreciated more easily.

In this community tank, they spend most of their time tucked away in the top right corner, occasionally shoaling together — although not nearly as often as my harlequin rasboras.

Behavior And Compatibility

They’re calm, peaceful fish, and I’ve never seen anything in this tank attempt to bother them.

Their small size and gentle nature make them an excellent community option, especially with shrimp and other peaceful species.

Corydoras

Some Of My Corydoras
Some Of My Corydoras

In this tank, I keep Corydoras aeneus, specifically the albino variety.

They’re on the chunkier side, and both of my females are currently spawning and full of eggs.

One even has a slight deformity on its back, but it hasn’t affected her health or behavior — they’re still fantastic fish.

Species Options

Albino and bronze Corydoras aeneus are among the most common and affordable varieties in the hobby, but there’s a huge range of other Corydoras species that also do well in community tanks.

Behavior And Diet

Corydoras are bottom dwellers that help keep the tank tidy by eating leftover food that sinks to the substrate.

Some people still claim they’re algae eaters, but to my knowledge, no Corydoras species actively eats algae.

They’re omnivores, and mine clearly prefer high-protein foods — especially Fluval Bug Bites Bottom Feeder Formula and frozen bloodworms.

They also have a playful, almost puppy-like personality.

They’ll come right up to the glass with those adorable faces as if to guilt-trip me into handing out extra treats — but I only indulge them on Sundays.

Benefits For The Tank

One big bonus of keeping Corydoras is the way they sift through the substrate while foraging.

This constant digging stirs up detritus and other debris, making it easier for the filter to remove.

Tank Suitability

Most Corydoras varieties stay relatively small, making them an excellent choice for a 40-gallon tank. They add constant activity and charm to the lower levels of the aquarium.

Neocaridina Shrimp

A Cherry Shrimp In My Tank
A Cherry Shrimp In My Tank

In this tank, I keep three types of Neocaridina shrimp — red cherry shrimp, along with yellow and orange morphs.

They’ve all been living together for over a year without issues.

While a few wild-type babies have appeared, most of the offspring are red, which makes sense since the majority of the original adults were red as well.

Benefits For The Tank

Neocaridina shrimp are excellent community tank additions.

They help control soft algae, keeping the glass and hardscape clean, while also eating leftover food and decaying plant matter.

This makes them both beautiful and functional in a 40-gallon setup.

Color And Cost

Even low-grade cherry shrimp add great pops of color to a community aquarium.

They’re easy to find, affordable, and just as effective as higher-grade varieties.

While many beginners are tempted to buy expensive, high-grade Neocaridina, I don’t think it’s worth the extra money in a busy community tank.

There’s already so much happening visually, and today’s “low-grade” shrimp still show plenty of vibrant color.

Amano Shrimp

Amano Shrimp In My Fish Tank
Amano Shrimp In My Fish Tank

Amano shrimp are, without a doubt, some of the best algae eaters I’ve ever kept. I currently have around six in this tank, and they’ve been a huge help in keeping things clean and balanced.

Benefits For The Tank

These shrimp are excellent at managing algae, leftover food, and decaying plant matter.

They’re especially effective when working alongside other cleanup crew members like Neocaridina shrimp, Nerite snails, and my Siamese algae eater.

Care And Suitability

Unlike some other Caridina species, Amano shrimp are hardy, low-maintenance, and very beginner-friendly.

For anyone looking to add a reliable algae eater to their community aquarium, they’re one of the best options available.

Nerite Snails

The final members of this tank’s cleanup crew are Nerite snails, specifically the smaller horned variety.

In a 40-gallon setup, you could also keep some of the larger types, such as zebra nerites, without any issues.

Benefits For The Tank

Nerite snails help control algae, eat leftover food, and consume decaying plant matter.

In this particular aquarium, they aren’t strictly necessary since the shrimp and Siamese algae eater already manage these tasks well, but they still provide extra support.

Population Control

One of the biggest advantages of Nerite snails is that, while they do lay eggs in freshwater, the eggs won’t hatch.

This means you don’t have to worry about a sudden snail population explosion in your tank — making them a very beginner-friendly option.

Final Thoughts

This 40-gallon community tank has been running successfully for about 18 months, and it’s been a rewarding experience watching these different species coexist.

Each fish and invertebrate adds something unique — from the peaceful honey gourami to the energetic harlequin rasboras, hardworking Corydoras, colorful shrimp, and reliable cleanup crew of Amano shrimp and Nerite snails.

When planning your own community aquarium, it’s important to remember that compatibility and water parameters matter more than trying to copy exact stocking numbers.

Every setup is different, so take the time to choose species that fit your water, tank size, and goals.

The combination I’ve shared here has worked beautifully in my tank, and I hope it gives you some inspiration for building your own thriving 40-gallon community aquarium.